As a lifelong Guns N’ Roses fan, Velvet Revolver appeared to be the natural transition following the dissolution of the original Guns N’ Roses lineup in the late 90s and while one shouldn’t compare the all-star lineup of Velvet Revolver, their songs are, for the most part, hard-hitting garage rock tunes that don’t break new ground but are a worthy addition to the rock and roll genre. That is if you can get over the crushed soundstage that is just grinding and at times intolerable.
Yes, dear reader, Velvet Revolver’s Contraband sounds like crap. It isn’t the performance, but the chosen recording style, mix and mastering. Loudness was thoroughly applied resulting in a massively compressed soundstage that comes across as noise, rather than a musical masterpiece. Even the ballad, Fall To Pieces is a noisy mess that lacks the definition and subtleties that are heard on basically every Guns N’ Roses album. Seriously, November Rain, Estranged, and Don’t Cry would have been absolute failures if they were mastered this badly. I simply can’t understand why musicians with such credibility would have allowed their music to be released in this manner.
To say Contraband needs a remaster is an understatement. Those of you who have been longtime readers of Subjective Sounds would likely be surprised at that statement but this is one album whereby the original release is arguably worse than the worst remaster I’ve ever come across. Yes, it is that bad. The current CD/Apple Music master is headache-inducing and while I love the performance and songs, I seldom listen to it because it is a sonic mess. I acknowledge that the vinyl release for Contraband is more dynamic but one can likely understand my scepticism given the dismal mastering quality of the digital release doesn’t exactly exude confidence in this music lover; especially when reviews have been mixed.
Unfortunately, when listening to the album I find that Matt Sorum’s drum performance is completely lost in the mix while Duff McKagan’s bass is only occasionally heard as a separate instrument. Thankfully, Slash is always loud and clear, but that is no surprise. Dave Kushner maintains the rhythm and Scott Weiland sang his ass off, yet there isn’t a standout element to be heard on Contraband. It is as if egos got the better of the musicians and each musician turned their performance up to eleven, thereby masking everyone else’s contribution. A shame, yes, but it’s just something us fans have to live with.
Sucker Train Blues is a promising start to the album, but the song is a sucker once it gets past its introduction. It is pure rock and roll but is the first of many examples of over-compression that takes away from the performance. Seriously, how distant is Sorum’s drumming on this track? It sounds like he isn’t even in the same studio and those cymbal crunches are just too crunchy with no decay present.
Do It For The Kids is “R&FNR” and is thoroughly enjoyable.
Big Machine is where, for me, Contraband begins. I would have loved to have this as the lead song with Sucker Train Blues and Do It For The Kids slotted into other positions in the tracking of the record. Nevertheless, Big Machine is a song that I love and one that everyone can relate to.
Illegal I Song suffers badly from the applied loudness, a shame considering it could have been significantly different. The mastering limitations here is what I call headache-inducing. It is, unfortunately, a song that I tend to skip.
Spectacle is a solid rock and roll tune. Nothing to write home about, but enjoyable nonetheless.
Fall To Pieces is a favourite of mine. I’d even go as far as calling it a masterpiece. While the story-arc is derived from Weiland’s battle with heroin and the impact it had on his wife, I believe that it’s a song that any of us can apply to various aspects of our lives as we’ve all had moments when we’ve fallen down and feel as though we’re falling to pieces. Fall To Pieces is also one of the tracks that don’t sound too bad given the heavy-handed loud mastering. I’d still like it to be more open and enveloping, but I love it anyway. A great song!
Headspace has a killer rhythm and is a great rock and roll tune. I love it!
Superhuman has the best guitar riff on the album. Brilliant! Similar to Headspace, the rhythm on Superhuman is off-the-charts.
Set Me Free is a bit of a mixed bag. It isn’t a bad song, but I don’t feel the chorus works, thereby making it somewhat lacklustre.
You Got No Right is a great song with a vocal styling that reminds me of Julian Lennon. In fact, I’d love to hear Lennon cover You Got No Right. Slash’s solo on this recording, while not revolutionary, is signature Slash and this fan thoroughly enjoys it.
Slither is, of course, Velvet Revolver’s trademark song and is bloody awesome with a mix and rhythm that is just right. The crunching cymbals persist, however, but little elements like that can be addressed should a remastering ever be undertaken. Additionally, Slither also won the Grammy award for Best Hard Rock Performance in 2005.
Dirty Little Thing is a bit of a letdown after Slither. It isn’t great. A B-side at best.
Loving The Alien is an incredible song to close the album on that encourages me to play it again and stay within Velvet Revolver’s small, but compelling, catalogue of music. Loving The Alien is one song where a remastering would send it skyrocketing to new heights as it is one of the best songs Velvet Revolver recorded.
Overall, Contraband is a sonic disaster but the songs are its redeeming quality. I look forward to the day when the album is reissued and remastered with kid gloves for I believe it deserves to be revisited and hopefully that will occur sooner, rather than later.
