Subjective Sounds

View Original

Lynyrd Skynyrd – Second Helping (Album Review)

Released in 1974, Second Helping is Lynyrd Skynyrd’s sophomore album and a powerful follow-up to their debut, (Pronounced 'Lĕh-'nérd ‘Skin-'nérd). Having already made waves with the masterful Free Bird, amongst many other (now) classic songs, does this follow-up match the musicality from their first album?

Yes, but also no. It’s complicated. Let me explain.

As pioneers of the Southern Rock genre, Lynyrd Skynyrd had a unique sound that rooted them firmly within the blues while also seeing them incorporate elements of country, rock, and a touch of funk. That fundamental aspect doesn’t change with this second release, and this record strengthens the band’s position and standing within the genre, but it’s also more hard rock-focused than the southern bluesy soft rock of the debut. In addition to that aspect, Second Helping is considerably more polished and layered, by comparison, thereby making it my favourite of their career.

Some of you may naturally have an opposite opinion, as music is highly subjective. Still, I find the cohesive nature of Second Helping to be stronger than the song selection and linear structure of (Pronounced 'Lĕh-'nérd ‘Skin-‘nérd). That isn’t to say that Second Helping is perfect, for I question the decision to include the J.J. Cale cover, Call Me The Breeze; a solid addition, yes, but one that doesn’t always compel me to play the record again as it’s a somewhat weak closing tune.

Either way, when you combine the higher production values, exceptional songwriting and overall performance, Second Helping could only have been bested if Call Me The Breeze had been omitted and my beloved Free Bird was added to the backend of the album. Naturally, that cannot happen, nor should it, for it would forever change the artistic direction of the band, but with that in mind, it’s clear to suggest that Second Helping was a worthy follow-up.

Speaking of production values, while the recording and mix are second to none, I feel the mastering could be a little more refined. Additionally, Don't Ask Me No Questions is more demo-styled than any other song from the album; an aspect that takes you temporarily out of the album listening experience. Nevertheless, when listening to the Lossless Apple Music stream, an Apple Digital Master, it’s thoroughly enjoyable but I’d also suggest that it’s merely adequate, rather than being exceptional. There are no glaring issues to report, it just doesn’t sound as immersive or sonically fluid as I'd ideally like and that, I feel, would likely come across well with regards to the various audiophile-based releases of this classic album. Of course, having not heard those other releases, I cannot comment on their sonic prowess, but a slight adjustment to one’s EQ settings could likely adjust the album to perfectly reflect one’s tastes.

See this content in the original post

Sweet Home Alabama kicks the album off with one of the most iconic riffs in rock and roll history. It may be Lynyrd Skynyrd’s most well-known song, for it’s a masterpiece, but it is worthy of inclusion amongst the songs that are considered part of the Great American Songbook for it’s one of the greatest songs ever written and recorded.

I Need You presents itself as a slow-burning, bluesy ballad that demonstrates the band’s versatility and while I Need You was never destined to be a hit, it’s one of their most pleasing tunes for the soulful and haunting guitar interplay between Allen Collins and Gary Rossington is exceptional, as is Ronnie Van Zant’s raspy, pleading vocals. The highlight for this music lover, however, is Ed King’s bass tracking which is subtle, yet extraordinary. The culmination of all aspects makes I Need You a hidden gem; particularly for those who are not familiar with Second Helping.

Don't Ask Me No Questions has a killer riff, funky rhythm, and a raw production style that appeals to the song, but it’s somewhat out of sync with the production standards heard throughout the rest of the album. Nevertheless, this Southern rock number is a solid addition, even if Don’t Ask Me No Questions is more akin to a demo than a fully-fledged song.

Workin' For MCA has a vibe that will get you moving as it dives into the complex relationship between artists and the record industry. Perhaps most interestingly, however, is that MCA Records allowed the song to be published. That in itself takes courage, but what can’t be denied is the musical prowess of this song as lyrical interpretation is one thing, but the musical bed, and that guitar solo, are simply sensational.

The Ballad Of Curtis Loew is a thoroughly pleasing blues-based number that, while not a standout, is a quintessential album-only tune.

Swamp Music, with its lively swampy groove, lives up to its title by embracing the bayou feel that is both infectious and fun.

The Needle And The Spoon has an incredible hook that is emphasised by the gritty lyrical topic and issues relating to not only addiction but the dangers of drug use. It’s moments like this that I celebrate enjoying music sans lyrics, with the vocalist becoming another instrument within the mix, for I can tune out the meaning and groove along to what I consider to be one of Lynyrd Skynyrd’s greatest tunes.

Call Me The Breeze is a solid cover of J.J. Cale’s original, from his 1972 release Naturally, yet despite Skynyrd's livelier presentation, it isn’t an ideal closing track as it seldom encourages me to listen to the album again. I’d also argue that Lynyrd Skynyrd was, by this stage, so well-established that the need to include a cover was superfluous to the album’s requirements and it’s a shame they didn’t have another song ready to go for their own compositions are incredible and have stood the test of time.

If nothing else, Second Helping strengthens the band’s influence for with this 1974 release, Lynyrd Skynyrd’s Southern sound, merged with the album’s raw energy and blend of blues, rock, and country elements, solidified their place in American rock whilst simultaneously creating a series of timeless songs that would ultimately result in one of the greatest albums of the 70s.

Check out more reviews by Subjective Sounds