Fleetwood Mac – Rumours (Album Review)
Some albums stand as towering achievements, timeless in their appeal and enduring in their impact. Fleetwood Mac's 1977 release, Rumours, is undoubtedly one of those albums. It's an iconic record that transcends the boundaries of time, genre, and taste, weaving a tale of love, heartbreak, and resilience that resonates with listeners across generations. This incredible release showcases the collective genius of Fleetwood Mac, a band that has left an indelible mark on the music industry while continuing to captivate audiences with their irresistible blend of rock, pop, and folk influences.
Of course, Fleetwood Mac has undergone several facets throughout their illustrious career. Some may be surprised to know that Rumours is, in fact, their twelfth studio release. Yet, talk to anyone about Fleetwood Mac and all you’ll likely hear is a discussion relating to how incredible Rumours is. While it is, and I acknowledge that it’s my favourite Fleetwood Mac album, I also appreciate that it wasn’t Peter Green’s Fleetwood Mac by this stage. Fleetwood Mac’s lineup would also change, throughout the following decades, so as much as the band is synonymous with Rumours, it is but one studio album from a diverse selection of 18 album releases. None of this should be seen as casting judgement on any of Fleetwood Mac's lineups, but you may find something subjectively wondrous should you take the time to listen to their entire discography.
As has already been established, Rumours is one of the greatest albums ever recorded, but it has been remastered too many times. When albums achieve the level of success that Rumours has, it’s not uncommon for the music industry to reissue and remaster the release ad nauseam, for it isn’t good enough to let the original masterpiece sit untouched. It can be a blessing or a curse, depending on your perspective, but one thing is certain, there are too many editions of Rumours. Seriously, Discogs, at the time of this publication, has some 694 different versions. Which one does one get? It’s a simple question, with a complicated answer that is so highly subjective that you’ll come across varying perspectives should you delve into further research online.
The truth is, I’ve heard multiple versions of this landmark release, over the years, that range from terrible to mind-blowing. Due to a series of circumstances, that I won’t bore you with, I’m currently without a physical release of this masterpiece and it pains me to say that the lossless Apple Music streamed edition just isn’t up to the highest standards. Frustratingly, Rumours was available as an Apple Digital Master, derived from the 2001 remastering, and while memory is fallible, as it pertains to sonic recollection, I do seem to recall it sounded fantastic. Perhaps not as good as other audiophile-based releases, but lovely nonetheless.
Disappointingly, it has been removed from Apple Music and while the version that remains is adequate, it isn’t quite as spectacular as one would hope. There is, of course, no point in complaining about this, but it is a real-world example of the risks associated with relying on a streaming service for one’s music collection. That said, if you’re still interested, as I am, in the Apple Digital Master, you can still purchase the 2001 remaster on iTunes. If you still prefer streaming and no longer wish to own the music you love, the 2001 remaster is still streaming on Qobuz; but for how much longer, nobody knows. Although, it appears that the removal of the 2001 remaster, from Apple Music, was more about adding the Dolby Atmos mix, which is based on the 2004 remaster (a non-Apple Digital Master).
At this stage, I’d just love for a singular version to exist that is the definitive release; one that matches the original artistic intent. We won’t get it, of course, as that is not how the music industry is run, but fans shouldn’t have to tolerate average-quality releases, nor should they have to spend their time, energy, and money, trying to figure out which of the over 600 editions would yield the greatest level of enjoyment.
Second Hand News isn’t the greatest song on the album, nor is it amongst Fleetwood Mac’s greatest recordings, yet something is compelling about Second Hand News, that I can’t quite put my finger on. Despite that, Rumours wouldn’t be the same album without it.
Dreams has an incredible introduction and likely would have been a stronger opener for the album. That aside, Stevie Nick’s haunting vocal is beyond reproach and perfectly suited to the style of the song, thereby ensuring her harmonious vocal intertwines well with the backing vocals. Dreams, also, is amongst my favourite songs from a drum perspective. Mick Fleetwood is a master musician and while his precision timing here may be akin to a click track for many, his delivery is the definition of perfection from my perspective. John McVie’s bass tracking is similarly masterful and, in many ways, Dreams is the enduring classic we all know and love because of the collaborative efforts of all band members.
Never Going Back Again is an acoustic gem with Lindsey Buckingham not only providing an incredible vocal performance, but his fingerpicking is taut and amongst some of the greatest guitar work I’ve ever had the pleasure of hearing.
Don’t Stop is a piece of sensational writing from Christine McVie. I’ve never been convinced, however, with Buckingham’s vocal on this tune. It’s not that it’s bad, and his guitar work is sensational, it’s just that the mix isn’t particularly solid. Buckingham’s vocal, subsequently, sounds as if he’s recording his vocals from another building, aside from the studio the song was recorded in. That said, Don’t Stop is a solid pop-rock tune.
Go Your Own Way needs no introduction, for you’ve been living under a rock if you’ve never heard this song. It’s sensational, one of Lindsay Buckingham’s best, and is a perfect tune to accompany life’s ups and downs.
Songbird is a tender ballad that showcases Christine McVie's extraordinary vocal talents. It's a moment of vulnerability on an otherwise emotionally charged album; a true masterpiece in every sense of the word.
The Chain is a killer tune that mixes rock and pop elements with a touch of country and is somewhat reminiscent of the sound the Eagles’ achieved on Desperado. However, The Chain is more than that correlation for its unmistakable bassline, harmonies, and anthemic chorus have made it a rock staple; one of the greatest ever recorded.
You Make Loving Fun is a great toe-tapping head-bopper and one that you should most certainly play as loud as you can. Rhythmically magical with a gorgeous vocal, and a killer guitar solo, You Make Loving Fun is one of the best songs off Rumours and another by McVie; arguably Fleetwood Mac’s greatest songwriter and songstress.
I Don’t Want To Know is a short but sweet burst of energy. Its brisk tempo and catchy hooks ensure it’s perfectly suited to Rumours despite being an album-only tune.
Oh Daddy is Fleetwood Mac 101. There is no other song that I identify more with the band than this one. It's career-defining and as much as I praise Christine McVie’s vocal contributions, Stevie Nicks’ vocal style was the correct choice for this classic track.
Gold Dust Woman is a haunting closing tune with Nicks’ ethereal vocal that leaves a lasting impression while simultaneously encouraging you to spin the album again.
Even Fleetwood Mac, themselves, could never replicate the success of Rumours and it’s highly unlikely that humanity, certainly in our lifetimes, will ever see such an era-defining album again. That isn’t to suggest it can’t be done, but Rumours was akin to lightning in a bottle and is not only one of the greatest albums ever recorded, but one that is a highlight of the 70s and will continue to stand the test of time as it is more than just an album; it’s a cultural remnant.